Skip to main content

Episode 162: Practicing Theological Triage with Gavin Ortlund


In theology, some hills are worth defending no matter the cost, and others are not. Which ones are worth it? When should doctrine divide? When should unity prevail? On today’s episode, Tim speaks with Dr. Gavin Ortlund (Ph.D.) on Christian responsibility to pursue both truth and love by offering biblical and theological guidance on distinguishing essentials from non-essentials in the faith, and they also talk about the virtue of humility in giving shape to disagreements.


Transcript

Tim Muehlhoff: 00:02 Welcome to the Winsome Conviction Podcast. My name is Tim Muehlhoff. I'm a professor of Communication at Biola University in La Mirada, California. I'm also the senior director of the Winsome Conviction Academy that seeks to open lines of communication, not close them. As I've mentioned before, uh Biola does a really cool thing in the fall. Every fall since 1936, Biola has closed down the entire university. We'll do it again for three days. And we bring in Bible teachers that we want to encourage students, exhort them, challenge them. For the last four years, in conjunction with the provost office, we've had money to bring in people to address the issue of civility. And so I'm very pleased to announce that the speaker for this year is Dr. Gavin Ortlund. He has a PhD from Fuller Theological Seminary in Historical Theology and an MDiv from Covenant Theological Seminary. He's a visiting professor of historical theology at Phoenix Seminary and theologian in residence at Emanuel Church in Nashville. He runs a YouTube channel, please check it out, called Truth Unites, that really does seek to provide a winsome and credible voice to the culture for the existence of God and the resurrection of Jesus. He's a prolific author, he's written over nine books. Two of them we're going to talk about uh in the next couple podcasts, but one today is an awesome book called Finding the Right Hills to Die On: The Case for Theological Triage from Crossway. When should doctrine divide and when should unity prevail? These are the kind of questions we want to ask to Dr. Ortlund. So, Gavin, welcome to the Winsome Conviction Podcast.

Gavin Ortlund
: 01:45 Great to be here. Thanks for having me. Looking forward to the conversation.

Tim Muehlhoff
: 01:48 Just to let you know, Gavin already spoke to our faculty. We had a faculty lunch, did a great job speaking on this topic. And then tomorrow, again, I don't know when you'll be listening to this. He'll be speaking to the entire student body. We'll be there to listen to him. We call it the Torrey Bible Conference. So, Gavin, thank you so much for speaking to our faculty today. Um, I found some of the things you said were really interesting when it comes to this idea of theological triage. But just for the sake of our listeners, why not explain that concept of theological triage, what you mean by that?

Gavin Ortlund
: 02:22 Sure. It's something that people might think of as kind of abstract and out there and doctrinal, but it's very practical. It's just the idea that we rank different issues. Some doctrines and some other practical issues are more important than others. And so we want to look at each issue. And some are, uh, as the title of the book implies, are they're hills to die on. They're, you know, uh to give an example, the the deity of Christ. Yeah, that is uh that is cardinal to the Christian faith. But there are so many other issues that maybe, maybe they still matter, maybe they're still important, but they're not as important. And then we just have to think through how do you relate to other Christians and have the love in your heart for them as your brother or sister in Christ, while recognizing we may have important differences. And so triaging issues is just a way to try to work through that with humility before the Lord.

Tim Muehlhoff
: 03:13 It's a great image. Now, very quickly, you mentioned to the faculty and in the book that we could say four buckets, we could rank or order four different categories. But just really quickly for our listeners who may not have read the book yet, what would be those four different buckets?

Gavin Ortlund
: 03:30 One way to chart this out is to have first rank issues that are essential to the gospel. So they mark off the boundaries of orthodoxy. Something like the doctrine of the Trinity, for example. Uh, second rank issues would then uh cause separation from one denomination to another or from one local church to another. They're not the gospel itself, but they matter and they affect which church we go to. Third rank issues are still important, and there can be some pretty important ones here that we may care about, but they don't need to require separation from other Christians. You could be maybe even on staff at a church with another pastor and have a disagreement. Fourth rank issues are things that just don't have any importance at all.

Tim Muehlhoff
: 04:13 Wow, that's I love that metaphor. So let me just give you, for instance, from my own life. So I'm at Eastern Michigan University. Um, I'm a theater major, but I'm also going with Campus Crusade for Christ. But I go to a free Methodist church. Absolutely love the church. The pastor's on fire, they're doing evangelism in the community. It's awesome. Then I learned he doesn't believe in eternal security. So I literally meet with him. We have coffee, and I said, uh, I need to leave the church. I can't be here. And he goes, Tim, do you not agree with our view of Jesus? And do you not agree with the Great Commission? Because that's really what we're about. Do you not think that we can disagree about eternal security? Okay, so take that scenario. Um, and where would you put that in your buckets?

Gavin Ortlund
: 04:58 That sounds like one that, oh boy, I hear these kinds of situations all the time, right? I mean, it that's the thing about this topic is it comes up and you're gonna be going through your life, following Jesus, trying to be a good church member, and something's gonna come up and there's gonna be disagreements in the body of Christ. Well, how do you handle that? I mean, that would be the kind of issue I would think so from what you're describing, it sounds like there could be a fruitful uh non-separation, there could be a fruitful unity that that can happen. Sometimes an issue will come in a context where there is um combativeness about it in the spirit with which it's held. And so that can elevate the importance of it in terms of how you're working through it, if it's actually becoming an issue of disunity at that point. Yeah. Um, so you have to pay attention to sort of how it's playing out and what is the context. But so many of these issues, even if they really matter, see, we're not saying the third rank issues don't matter, but what we're saying is there's an overriding value of the unity of the body of Christ. So we don't want to separate unless we have to.

Tim Muehlhoff
: 05:58 Yeah. And as a as a 19-year-old, I marched out of that church. No, I did not. As a 19-year-old, I sat with him and I said, Well, you know what? I I love this church. And he said, Well, listen, let's come and learn. I'm not asking you to sign off on eternal security. So we can just have a gentleman's disagreement on this and let's go lead people to Christ. And as a 19-year-old involved with Campus Crusade for Christ, that just really resonated with me, and I stayed. It really never became an issue. Like he didn't preach on this, and but it was like this background noise. But I stayed there and learned a ton from them, the whole church staff. And I still believe in eternal security, but I do like that idea of maybe there's maybe there's rank order first things. I think the Great Commission, salvation upon Christ alone, that kept us together as we had this other disagreement. One thing you said to the faculty that I thought was really good, you made the comment that more important than correctly ranking theology is that we should have humility. I I really like that. Can you expound on that?

Gavin Ortlund
: 07:09 This is what I found is that uh being technically correct in our thinking, of course, we want we want to strive after the Lord with all of our mind. We want to think carefully and wisely and study, but that is not the main driving factor for how something might play out in terms of its spiritual consequences. Uh, it's there, but also there is the spirit with which we hold our views. And I have found that humility before God and humility before his word may be the most important thing so that when we arrive upon a conviction, the spirit with which we hold it is one where there's minimal collateral damage around us. And I interviewed a number of pastors before writing this book and uh wanting to know of the actual on-the-ground experiences that that play out. How does this show up? And it was a pastor in Singapore who told me he's seen theological disagreements play out in two different ways. Sometimes they are profoundly destructive, other times they are serious, but they don't have that same bad fruit. And he said, what makes the difference is humility. Oh man. People approach it in a spirit of I don't have all the answers. I'm uh gonna be a good listener, I'm gonna try to draw out the other perspective and understand and so forth. So uh that that's a always good thing to come back to.

Tim Muehlhoff
: 08:25 So I'm a communication professor, but my specialty is actually conflict resolution between groups. So that's a different ball game than you and I having a conflict at Starbucks. When groups get together, it's hard because is there an official spokesperson? Uh, and even if there is an official spokesperson, do other people say things that even on social media disagree with what the official spokesperson said? Um, uh, so that's kind of my specialty. My wife laughs at that periodically, that my specialty is conflict resolution. I I think I'm good at the theory part of it. But but what you just said about with the pastor from Singapore, if you resolve this in a way that is healthy, it actually brings us closer together. We know that in marital communication, we know that in community building, if we can resolve a conflict in a way that both sides feel like there was give and take, that actually makes the community much stronger. So maybe some of these disagreements, theological disagreements, can actually bring us together and not rip us apart.

Gavin Ortlund
: 09:33 Yeah. Oh, that that that's the dream scenario, I think, for any pastor listening to this, and maybe they're facing uh disagreements in their congregation is what you pray for is that not only would it not harm the church, how could God use this to grow us into maturity in Christ? And even if you get to a point where there is a necessary separation at an institutional level, how can we bless one another in the context of that? So we're not leaving with a sense of enmity in our hearts, but we still love and and even, Lord willing, speak well publicly of the other party where where is appropriate.

Tim Muehlhoff
: 10:09 Can we just pause for a second what you just said? Speak well of the people we disagree with. Boy, that's a that's an oddity today, and that happens in today's argument culture. Uh, you did a really nice job of laying out two different intentions, but but their intention, because they're both equally commitments of the evangelical church. One is unity and then one is truth, and we're not getting rid of either. But just for a second, let's talk about the unity part and then we'll transition to the truth part. It really struck me some of the unity um uh scenarios that you were bringing up. Uh so fascinating that you're a historical theologian. Just for a second, break that down for our listeners. What does it mean to be a historical theologian? It's just studying the theology of the church throughout time.

Gavin Ortlund
: 11:01 So uh uh church history, but with a specific focus on the the theology, the ideas, uh, how people are reflecting upon God and the gospel and so forth.

Tim Muehlhoff
: 11:10 That's great. And you did a marvelous job of mentioning uh certain historical figures. Just for a second, Richard Baxter actually wrote a book on division. Yes?

Gavin Ortlund
: 11:22 Yeah, The Cure for Church Divisions, amazingly convicting book.

Tim Muehlhoff
: 11:25 And what give me the basic year of that book?

Gavin Ortlund
: 11:28 Uh, I don't remember. Okay. Um but a while ago, like several hundred years ago.

Tim Muehlhoff
: 11:33 Yeah, yeah. He he said something that I thought was really good about the war, the warmth, uh a warm place in your heart towards people you disagree with?

Gavin Ortlund
: 11:43 That that quote is Spurgeon.

Tim Muehlhoff
: 11:45 Oh, okay, yeah, yeah. That was my other one. Okay, that's my bad. But talk about Baxter real quick, and then we'll get to the Spurgeon one.

Gavin Ortlund
: 11:51 He did have a similar image. Uh he's he's taught he's giving a rebuke to those who are correcting their theological opponents, and they're correcting them with zeal, with the sense of tenacity. And he said, watch that tenacity, watch that zeal. And he says mark whether it has more love in it or more enmity in it. Oh wow. Is that zeal there to heal or to injure? Is it there to create parties and divisions or to bring uh unity in the truth? And uh he says the uh that that harsh zeal that has no love in it, even if it is doctrinally correct, can be used of Satan to crop to create damage to the body of Christ. And he's pretty uh direct in his warning there. And he's drawing from New Testament passages like the book of James. And I just find the uh that that is a very appropriate warning for those of us who do love theological clarity, and we should love theological clarity, and we should value truth, and we should be willing to stand courageously on the truth and take hits for it when we need to, but sometimes we can do that in a way that lacks charity, and that is we feel this zeal and excitement, but actually what we're doing is injuring people.

Tim Muehlhoff
: 13:13 Okay, so Gavin, what would you say? Okay, so I'm just channeling our critics. Like last year, uh our listeners know it was a pretty rough year. We we had some online critics, Christians, um, come after us pretty hard. Um I think they would say this. I think they would say, Yeah, I'm injuring for sure in order to heal. Yeah, I'm coming out hard against Biola, but my intent is that this correction, which is hard, I'm sure, for them to hear Biola, but I'm doing it in order to heal what I see as a drift towards progressivism or liberalism. So I think they might say, Oh, I'm absolutely loving Biola University and my harshness because they need a course correct and they need it now.

Gavin Ortlund
: 14:05 Yeah. So it helps me in thinking this through to start with there really is no way around the tough question of truth. Is it actually the case that the issues being addressed require the kind of rebuke being given? And there's no I don't know any shortcut to get to that answer. We have to look at each thing. Because to steel man and and uh try to be fair to this concern that you're putting into words here, there are times for harsh rebuke. There are times for uh fierce warnings, there are times to speak bluntly. And that's actually, you know, my comments today at lunch to the faculty were very much acknowledging that, saying, here's truth, here's unity. Both of these values are are gonna pull us in a direction. The truth value will pull us to moments like Martin Luther saying, Here I stand, I can do no other. There are hills to die on. Yeah, the question is, what are those hills? And this is where my concern comes in is that sometimes Christians can uh target their brother or sister in Christ as if they were a wolf or heretic or false teacher. Right. And that's where Baxter's warning about uh a loveless zeal can come up. So it's it the the issue is what are the issues meriting the rebuke? Do they really warrant them? Yeah, yeah, yeah. Sometimes they can, but we can very easily get there. And I would just say to anyone who's gonna give a harsh criticism, please understand how serious of a matter this is. If you're gonna call someone a false teacher, you know, I've been called a heretic and a false teacher and so forth. If you if you're gonna use the New Testament's most severe language, yeah, you need to have a you need to be correct in that. And then if you are incorrect in that, you need to be able to acknowledge if you made a mistake. You need to be willing to, I would say, engage with others of a different perspective to listen to a counter perspective. Um, what we don't want to do is recklessly uh uh criticizing others. So there's a time for a harsh rebuke, but I just I think we get there too quickly sometimes.

Tim Muehlhoff
: 16:20 Yeah, I think I I think you're right. And again, putting on my communication theory hat, one of the defense mechanisms we definitely have is because I do not like your tone, I discount your critique. That tone I don't appreciate, thus that gives me an get out of jail card to any of the criticism. So even if someone does it incorrectly based on our assessment, like that was way too harsh. I still need to be able to step back with humility and say, but I probably should consider a couple of those critiques.

Gavin Ortlund
: 16:54 1000%. I mean, what you're saying right now is perhaps the biggest lesson that I've had to come back to in my own life is when criticism comes, not every time, but most of the time you can learn something because we are all fallible, we're all finite. And it has helped me to come back to this place to say, how does this criticism help me depend upon the Lord more?

Tim Muehlhoff
: 17:14 Yeah.

Gavin Ortlund
: 17:15 Even if it's not fully accurate. Yeah. And there may be a place where actually it's it's in some cases, it can even be harassment. And I'm thinking of some extreme situations where I've experienced things that I think I need to use that word for. And even there, it's like Paul's asking about the thorn in the flesh to be gone. And God says, sometimes even there, there's a space to say, God, I I I yield to you, I fall at your feet. Um, help me to learn what I need to learn right now. And I'll put take steps to protect myself too when I can. Yeah. But ultimately, just uh coming back before God Himself and saying, and I think a willingness to learn from criticism is just so important, something to come back to each time, even if it's unfair.

Tim Muehlhoff
: 17:55 Yeah. So let me compliment you. Um, and we had this talk as we were going to get coffee, because you cannot do a podcast without coffee. Let's not go to the dark ages. Um, you we both have experienced uh a critique of Megan Basham. We both have. I honestly think, and I've already bought all your books, so this is not an issue of sales. I honestly think it was a masterclass how you responded to Megan. She did it publicly in a book uh called Shepherds for Hire.

Gavin Ortlund
: 18:27 Shepherds for Sale.

Tim Muehlhoff
: 18:28 Shepherds for Sale. Even worse, maybe. Um, and you were mentioned along with Biola faculty, were mentioned as well. Um I I thought the way you addressed it was a master class in both tone and you went to the facts and and had a dispute about facts, right? Particularly how you'd been quoted. Right. So I I just encourage our listeners to go back and watch, and this is all public knowledge uh to watch your response. I really thought, so what did it take for you to get there that I'm going to respond, but in a way that you feel like is charitable? Um, how what kind of soul searching did that take for you to come to the place where I'm I'm gonna choose to respond?

Gavin Ortlund
: 19:16 This is one of the biggest issues where I feel I need the Lord's wisdom regularly is responding to criticism. When someone publicly criticizes you, many times it's best to not respond. And you know, you can't respond to every criticism. You can't. Yeah. Sometimes you do need to, or it is good to, and it's very tough to know when. I put a lot of prayer into that one. Uh, Paul, I always think of 2nd Corinthians. Paul is not going on and on in every single one of his letters saying uh defending himself from criticisms, but there are times in 2nd Corinthians where he defends his ministry. Right. And in that case, and in a few others where I have responded to criticism, I have done so, I hope. And my motives are always imperfect. And I, you know, I I'm not uh I'm a work in progress on all this. But my I hope the motive is I need to serve the sheep. I'm seeing a narrative being spread. In point of fact, that narrative is simply incorrect, and words are being mangled. You know, in this case, it was pretty blatant some of the sentences being changed from I'm talking about how you form a view, and words are quoted and applied to what view you come to. Right. And that's an just an objectively different meaning. And so in addressing that, I think it's fair game to do that, but the motive is not just to get that's the thing, we can't get into these interminable back and forths. What we want to do is try to serve our viewers. And sometimes we have to do that to serve people who are being influenced. And this is the tricky thing. I think we could be tempted to respond too much to criticism, but I also think we could be tempted to respond too little.

Tim Muehlhoff
: 20:55 I really agree with that. It's the balance, it's discernment, it's wisdom. By the way, listeners, go listen to our interview with JD Greear. Uh, he found himself in the same kind of position you were, and we actually asked him about it, and he did a marvelous job uh helping us work through how he got to the point that he thought he'd publicly respond as well. Um, so you're right, we can do too much, and I think we can do too little. Let's end with a test case. And I love the fact that you're a historical theologian. So if I wrote this down correctly, Spurgeon and George Herbert? Yeah, Herbert, yep. Yeah, okay, they had a disagreement. Yeah, but it's what Spurgeon said that to me was so beautiful, even within this disagreement, he held himself to a certain standard. Yeah. And so unpack that just for a little bit as we wrap up this segment.

Gavin Ortlund
: 21:45 I'm so glad you're asking this to finish with. This is a great note to land on, right? Uh, what Spurgeon said, and people can read the full quote in the book, or or even uh I think I put it out in a few videos as well. He's speaking of his love for George Herbert, despite theological disagreements, and he hasn't. Passage where he he speaks of having a warm corner in your heart for every Christian. And I think that that is uh such a helpful image when we're responding to criticism. It's easy for our flesh to get involved. We don't want that to be the case. We want to respond with love for the critic. We pray for that person, we keep an open heart for things improving, things getting better. We respond with love for the broader body of Christ. We want to see the body of Christ built up. And so that's the motive. It's not about defending ourselves. We want the church. And I think uh destructive criticism, especially online, does harm the body of Christ. And we want to see the body of Christ built up. So we speak out in love for that. And I think Spurgeon just gives us the great reminder there. Let's have a warm corner in our heart for every true Christian. And Jesus will help us with that. We just go to, we don't have to manufacture that. We can go for collapse at his feet. And he will love us and he will pour his love into our hearts to enable us to do that.

Tim Muehlhoff
: 22:58 So I immediately think of two quotes that just haunt me. One from uh Paul, forgive as you have been forgiven. And the second is Lewis Smede's great book on uh forgiveness, where his last one, Gavin, is the worst. It's the worst diagnostic. I just hate that I read it. So it ruined my life. So let me ruin the lives of the listeners. He said, Here's a litmus task. Do you pray for the well-being? The person who hurt you. Oh, Gavin, that is so hard to have that warm place in my heart. And what a great diagnostic that I don't. And it's okay, it's okay to pray, God, I don't right now. But what do I need to do to get it?

Gavin Ortlund
: 23:38 Yes, and ask the Lord, and He can help us. There's a can I finish with a story about this that can help us from Corrie Ten Boom, who uh was this amazing woman of God and saw one of a person who had mistreated her asked for forgiveness and she was struggling. And she to collapse it down and summarize, she basically prayed, cried out to the Lord, and she shook this man's hand and felt a warmth going through her arm and uh said of a love that I could not understand, could not manufacture, came over me and flowed through me for this man. And she said, she realized the forgiveness we offer to people, the love we offer, it's not our own. It's Christ's. Yeah, and it flows through us. We don't need to manufacture the results, but we can just basically commune with Christ ourselves, and then his love and his forgiveness will, Lord willing, flow through us. And as we fall away from that, we just come back to the Lord.

Tim Muehlhoff
: 24:32
And you know what's interesting about that, Gavin, is that story uh that isn't having to do about online criticism that Corrie is struggling with. It's the death of her sister. And and this gentleman came up and to her reflected the people that were responsible for her death. And that's where she extended forgiveness, right?

Gavin Ortlund
: 24:52 Amazing.

Tim Muehlhoff
: 24:53 We can handle online criticism. I can't even begin to think walking in Corrie's shoes to having to forgive the death of her sister. Um hey, thank you so much. Would you come back on our podcast and tackle some other issues? I'd love to. Let's do it. Well, thank you for being here and thank you for serving Biola with the Torrey Bible Conference. You've been listening to the Winsome Conviction podcast. If you want to find out more about us, go to winswomanconviction.com. You can find all the back interviews, including the one I mentioned by JD Greear. Uh, you can also sign up for our quarterly newsletter, let you know what's happening. Some really cool things God's given us the opportunity to do. Go ahead and give us a like, and uh, we'll be talking to you soon.

Share: