| Year | Most Valuable Player | Most Improved Player | ||
| 2004 | Carl Galloway | Sal Poti | ||
| Reid Hamblet - Most Valuable Pitcher | ||||
| 2003 | Sam Orr, Carl Galloway | Eric Schelling | ||
| Ryan Klatt - Most Valuable Pitcher | ||||
| 2002 | Carl Galloway | Matt Parrish | ||
| 2001 | Ben Orr | Ryan Beaver | ||
| Chad Ekin - Most Valuable Pitcher | ||||
| 2000 | Nate Hansen | Eric Slater | ||
| Chad Ekin - Most Valuable Pitcher | ||||
| 1999 | Jonathon Rouwenhorst | Matt Cardamone | ||
| Ben Orr - Most Valuable Pitcher | ||||
| 1998 | Joel Marsh, Bryn Wade | Chris Petinak | ||
| Ben Orr - Most Valuable Pitcher | ||||
| 1996 | Scott Allen | |||
| 1995 | Brian Schmidt | |||
| 1994 | Brian Schmidt | |||
| 1993 | Tyler Williamson | |||
| 1992 | Jeff Boyle | Ken Mason | ||
| 1991 | Fred Speck | |||
| 1990 | Bob Keller, Tim Worrell | Gary Warner | ||
| 1989 | Brett Thorsteinson | Gordon Jorgenson | ||
| 1988 | Craig Jutila | Bill Blakely | ||
| 1987 | Carl Johnson | Bill Blakely | ||
| 1986 | Matt Suttle | Tate Crenshaw | ||
| 1984 | Steve Spencer | Doug Wick | ||
| 1983 | Ted Riche | Randy Brouwer | ||
| 1980 | Jim Price | Dan Ferguson | ||
| 1979 | Dave Disbro | Dave Suderman | ||
| 1978 | Dave Disbro | Dan Wild | ||
| 1977 | Dan Wild | Paul Jansson | ||
| 1976 | Dave Ludwig | Joey Somawang | ||
| 1975 | Richard Clark | Ted Ferguson | ||
| 1974 | Scott Fisher | Tom Cowles | ||
| 1973 | Mike Edward | Joel Campbell | ||
| 1972 | Jim Hill | Tom Wright | ||
| 1971 | Jim Hill | Jim Hill | ||
| 1970 | Bob Goodwin | Joel Campbell | ||
| 1969 | Mike Nichols | Darrell Bye | ||
| 1968 | Mike Nichols | |||
| 1967 | Tim Hewes | Mike Nichols | ||
| 1966 | Dennis Rasmussen | |||
| 64-65 | Paul Berry | |||
| 63-64 | Wendell Bonee | |||
| 62-63 | Richard Reed | |||
| 61-62 | Wendell Bonee | |||
| 60-61 | Wendell Bonee | |||